
How to Find Off-Market Properties Like a Pro

When you start learning about real estate, you’ll come across lots of new terms. One that often confuses people is “off market.” You might wonder what it means or why it matters. In this post, we’ll explain the idea of off-market deals and show why they can be great opportunities for buyers and investors.
What Does Off-Market Mean in Real Estate?
An “off-market” property is one that’s not listed on the MLS (Multiple Listing Service)—the place where most homes are posted when they’re for sale. This means the home isn’t advertised publicly. But even though it’s not online or in real estate ads, the owner may still be open to selling.
So, what is an off-market listing? It’s a home that’s for sale quietly, often shared only with a small group of agents or buyers. These listings are also called pocket listings or private sales.
Sometimes, a homeowner is just thinking about selling but hasn’t decided yet. Other times, they only want certain buyers to know the home is available. Either way, these off-market deals can be a smart way to buy a home with less competition.
Finding Off-Market Properties
Off-market properties can be hidden gems, but since they aren’t publicly listed, you have to know where to look. Below are several ways to find these types of homes. Whether you're an investor or a first-time buyer, these methods can help you find great deals before anyone else even knows they exist.
Network with Real Estate Agents and Investors
Real estate professionals are often the first to know about homes that might be sold quietly. Some sellers prefer not to list their homes publicly, and agents keep these properties in their personal networks. Investors also share leads with each other. Going to local meetups or joining real estate groups online can help you connect with people who know about off-market properties before they hit the market.
Send Direct Mail to Homeowners
One of the most effective ways to reach homeowners is by sending direct mail. You can write a friendly letter or postcard letting them know you’re interested in buying a home in their area. This personal approach works especially well if the homeowner has thought about selling but hasn’t made it official yet. Even if they weren’t planning to sell, a polite offer could change their mind.
Drive for Dollars
Driving for dollars is a simple strategy where you drive through neighborhoods looking for homes that appear vacant, run-down, or poorly maintained. These might be signs that the owner is ready to sell. Once you spot a property, you can look up the owner’s information and reach out with a letter or a phone call.
Search Public Records and Legal Notices
Foreclosure filings, probate court records, divorce filings, and tax delinquency notices are often available through your local courthouse or government website. These records can point you toward motivated sellers. It may take more time and effort to go through them, but the payoff could be a great deal.
Use Off-Market Property Tools and Apps
Apps like DealMachine help people find off-market real estate opportunities by making it easy to search properties, see ownership info, and send mail directly from your phone. These tools are built for investors but can work for anyone trying to find a good home off the beaten path.
See David and Ryan's 3 steps to finding off-market properties below.
Negotiating Off-Market Properties
Once you find an off-market property, the next step is knowing how to negotiate. These deals are often more personal since there’s no listing agent or public marketing involved. This gives you more room to build trust and work out a deal that benefits both sides.
Do Your Homework
Before making an offer, research the property. Check recent sales in the area, find out what repairs might be needed, and figure out its fair market value. Having this information helps you make a smart offer and shows the owner you’re serious.
Be Respectful and Patient
Sellers of off-market homes might not be in a rush. They could still be deciding if they even want to sell. Be kind, patient, and understanding. A respectful attitude can go a long way in building a connection and getting a yes.
Build a Relationship
In these types of deals, the owner is dealing with you directly. This gives you a chance to create a more personal connection. Listen to their concerns and goals. Sometimes understanding why they’re selling can help you offer terms that work for both of you.
Make a Strong Offer
If possible, get pre-approved for a loan or offer cash. A solid offer with few conditions can stand out. Since this isn’t a public sale, the seller might choose your offer just because it’s simple and reliable.
Learning what is an off-market listing and how to approach it with confidence can open the door to deals that others miss. With the right attitude and preparation, negotiating off-market properties can lead to big wins.
Pros and Cons of Buying Off Market
Buying an off-market property can be a smart move—but it’s not always easy. Here are a few pros and cons to help you decide if it’s the right path for you.
Pros:
- Less Competition: Since the home isn’t listed publicly, fewer buyers know about it. This gives you a better chance of making a deal.
- Better Prices: With no bidding war, you might get the home for less.
- More Flexibility: Sellers may be more open to your terms, especially if they’re not in a rush.
Cons:
- Harder to Find: These deals take more time and effort to locate.
- Less Information: Without a full listing, you might not know everything about the home right away.
- Unclear Market Value: You’ll need to do more research to make sure you’re paying a fair price.
Final Thoughts
Off-market properties might seem like a mystery at first, but now you know they can be a smart way to find your next deal. These homes aren’t always easy to spot, but with the right tools and approach, you can uncover real opportunities. Whether you're a first-time buyer or a seasoned investor, learning how to connect with sellers directly can give you an edge.
Remember, patience and research go a long way. The more you practice finding and negotiating off-market deals, the easier it gets. Stay curious, build relationships, and don’t be afraid to take that extra step.

About Samantha Ankney
Samantha is the Social Media Manager at DealMachine, where she oversees all social media strategies and content creation. With 3 years of experience at the company, she originally joined as a Media Specialist, leveraging her skills to enhance DealMachine's digital presence. Passionate about connecting with the community and driving engagement, Samantha is dedicated to sharing valuable insights and updates across all platforms.